New York Islanders Logo

Before the 1995–96 season, the Islanders attempted to update their look. The result was the unveiling of a logo depicting a fisherman holding a hockey stick. The logo was a marketing disaster; the reaction among the fan base was so negative that management announced it would revert to the original logo as soon as league rules allowed them to do so. Many fans found that the logo bore a strong resemblance to the Gorton's fisherman; indeed, New York Rangers fans taunted the Islanders with chants of "we want fishsticks" long after the logo was discarded. The traditional logo was phased back in over the next two seasons, starting as an alternate jersey logo in 1996–97 before fully replacing the fisherman in 1997–98. The only change to the classic logo at this time was its colors; as the team had replaced its original royal blue with navy, the logo was recolored to match.

Beginning in 2008, the Islanders introduced another modification to their original logo for their new third jersey. The "new" logo, once again in royal blue, now features four orange stripes on the hockey stick instead of three, representing the four consecutive Stanley Cup titles in the 1980s. This became the team's full-time logo in 2010 when the team retired their inaugural Reebok Edge uniforms.

In the 2011–12 season, the Islanders added a third jersey. This one was primarily black with the word "Islanders" written in orange on the front and numbers centered under. This also marked the second time the Islanders introduced the color gray into their uniforms, the first time since the "fisherman era."

For the 2014 NHL Stadium Series, the Islanders used a new logo with the "NY" with the hockey stick found on the team's main jersey in chrome. Beginning with the 2014-15 NHL season, the NY logo is used on the team's third jersey.